jmills, or angry

[mopap]

I'm not sure you can fix the D3 debacle. At the least you should call and end to the day with a lynch of PB, and you should let his kill of whomever go through, even if that's one of us. But maybe none of that is possible at this point.

[ugluk]

I think if peace did shoot charlie, charlie should be dead. I posted at 4.59 which was 1 minute after peace said to shoot charlie but before theory lynched him.

[greco]

i agree with allowing pb to have his shot if time stamps can prove it.

[mopap]

Time stamps are over-rated. PB wanted to kill someone, snow wanted to kill PB. Let both happen. And end the day. The village lynched PB. Just go to the night stage. Otherwise, this game might loose steam.

[anborn]

i think we need to move on. the thread indicates they resolved it and PB seems happy. Next time don't be so eager to use the vig when it looks like the village was going to do our work for us.

[ugluk]

if i had another move other than a one time kill of boromir I wouldnt have vig'd him. confusion is good for us.

[anborn]

we will see. just seems odd that we are going to take out a person getting runup who has claimed indy, who is about to take out another GG on his way out... seems like 2 > 1. of course its a wash that creates slight if they end up lynching a GG tonight... but with myself as the next in line, it seems risky. again just my 2nd game, so maybe i don't know.

[mopap]

May 8, 2008 20:00:55 GMT -5 ugluk said:

if i had another move other than a one time kill of boromir I wouldnt have vig'd him. confusion is good for us.

But you cleared things up killing him. Much better to let him be lynched. If he'd gotten out of it, then kill him. Personally, I think we're screwed. I'm curious why his kill of CH didn't go through. Thought you said that should have been time-stamped before yours.

[greco]

May 8, 2008 20:11:05 GMT -5 mopap said:

May 8, 2008 20:00:55 GMT -5 ugluk said:

if i had another move other than a one time kill of boromir I wouldnt have vig'd him. confusion is good for us.

But you cleared things up killing him. Much better to let him be lynched. If he'd gotten out of it, then kill him. Personally, I think we're screwed. I'm curious why his kill of CH didn't go through. Thought you said that should have been time-stamped before yours.

Water under bridge...

[mopap]

May 8, 2008 20:48:27 GMT -5 greco said:

May 8, 2008 20:11:05 GMT -5 mopap said:

But you cleared things up killing him. Much better to let him be lynched. If he'd gotten out of it, then kill him. Personally, I think we're screwed. I'm curious why his kill of CH didn't go through. Thought you said that should have been time-stamped before yours.

Water under bridge...

Comes back as rain to bite you in the ass.

[jmills]

just to confirm to you guys that even though there was some confusion earlier, the write-up is correct. Guppy and I have straightened it out. There are no other kills and D3 continues.

[mopap]

May 8, 2008 21:17:33 GMT -5 jmills said:

just to confirm to you guys that even though there was some confusion earlier, the write-up is correct. Guppy and I have straightened it out. There are no other kills and D3 continues.

Oh, I got that part.

[ugluk]

and they're confused. just lay a vote or two on charlie.

[mopap]

They are too smart for that wonder boy.

[anborn]

i think one or both of you needs to back off all this night talk... you guys are coming off as trying to lead. which if thats what your goal is, fine... but both of you is a little fishy.

tonight and the first few hours tomorrow are going to set the stage for a bit. need to play it careful.